SAY NOT THE STRUGGLE NAUGHT AVAILETH (1)
GOOD NEWS!
The malign influence of the Catastrophic, Anthropogenic Global Warming meme (CAGW) (2) that escaped more than 40 years ago to infect the world like a virus from a Wuhan Lab, is finally beginning to collapse.
THE EVIDENCE is CLEAR
Despite $16 trillion (a conservative estimate by Bjorn Lomberg) spent by world governments in CO2 abatement schemes over the past 25 years, atmospheric levels of CO2 have continued their steady rise.
Today fossil fuels provide more than 86% of our energy needs: 25 years ago, it was 88%. Most of the balance, then as now, comes from nuclear and hydro (3). Although the amount of energy derived from wind and solar installations has increased over that period, so too have all other sources of energy. New wind and solar have been additional, not transformational. A rising tide of demand has lifted all boats. There has been No Significant Energy Transition.
A rising tide lifts all boats. (Click for larger, sharper image)
World Energy Production in 2025. Source: Statistical Review of World Energy
With the best sites already taken, new wind and solar “farms” are having to be built in widely scattered, remote, onshore or offshore locations. This requires thousands of kilometers of new transmission lines to link these dispersed sources and bring them to population centers where they are needed. That costs much more than the generators themselves. Governments attempt to overcome this problem with large subsidies, but the capacity of even rich countries to do this is limited. The resulting distribution bottlenecks will make the renewable installations currently being built stranded assets (see: Barclays Transition Realism White Paper February 2026 for a detailed argument on this case).
Despite increasing atmospheric CO2 levels and a small but steady rise in global average temperature (4) over the past 150 years all measures of human wellbeing – wealth, health, nutrition, clean water, education etc. – show that humanity is thriving. But the killer metric – the one that encapsulates all others, is longevity. According to Our World in Data, in 1900 average global life expectancy at birth was 32 years; in 1950 it was 45 years; in 2021 it was 70 years while today (2025) it is 73 years. Huge relative inequities still remain of course (700 million have no access to electricity), but the poor of yesterday would consider themselves rich if they had even half the comforts, amenities and opportunities available to the poor of today. Most of that improvement in human welfare is the result of cheap energy derived from fossil fuels.

Official figures from Government agencies showing dramatic improvement in six categories of human welfare – Poverty, Education, Literacy, Democracy, Vaccination Rates and Child Mortality – over the past 200 years. There is no existential crisis. Humanity is thriving.
In Paris in 2015 the 21st annual United Nations Conference on Climate Change (known as the Conference of Parties, or COP 21), concluded with an agreement that participating countries should take steps to move the world to Net Zero human carbon dioxide emissions by 2050. The agreement was aspirational, not legally binding or enforceable.
Paris 2015: Hubris
On its own insistence, China (who, in 2025, built one new coal-fired power station per week and currently emit almost as much CO2 as the rest of the world combined) was exempted from the Agreement on the self-proclaimed grounds that it was a “Developing Nation”. China got to move their net zero aspirations to 2070. Genuine Developing Nations were given a similar free pass.
North American and European countries were the first to ratify the 2015 Paris Agreement and became the most enthusiastic implementers of Net Zero programs. As a result, they have seen their electricity prices soar and their energy-intensive industries close or move offshore. Increasingly, East and South Asian countries, particularly China, have become the manufacturers of much of the world’s industrial and consumer goods
Even as many countries continue to protest that they are still true believers (just give us more time and more money), Governments are slowly waking up to the reality that, although energy from the sun and wind is free and renewable, the machines, devices and wires required to capture, store and distribute it most definitely are not. Even true believers are now beginning to realise that the cost is ruinous.
These machines and devices are largely bought from China who are able to make them more cheaply than anyone else because their industries use cheap power derived from burning from fossil fuels, especially coal. There are no prizes for guessing where a large proportion of the Western World’s $16 trillion has gone.
World Coal Consumption 1965 to 2025
The result of this wealth transfer from West to East is easily demonstrated by one simple metric. According to the International Monetary Fund World Economic Outlook, in 2025 the GDP (Gross Domestic Product) of India rose by 6.6% and in China by 4.8%. Compare this with the United States at 2.2%, United Kingdom 1.3%, Japan 1.1%, France 0.3%. Germany 0.2% and Australia, a miserable last among OECD countries, just 0.1 %.
As a result, western countries are scaling back on ambitions to power their economies solely with wind and solar. Instead, they are re-opening or refurbishing coal-fired power stations, building new ones and scrambling to sign up new coal, oil and gas supplies. But great damage has already been done and the transition to rational energy policy is slow and dependent on changing political fortunes and the willingness of taxpayers to foot the ever-increasing bill.
In 2021 (the 5th Anniversary of Paris) COP25 was held in the city of Glasgow, Scotland. Welcoming the delegates, Prince Charles (now King Charles) described the meeting as “the last chance saloon” for climate action. At the meeting, Scott Morisson the Prime Minister of Australia and a former fierce champion of fossil fuels, in an apparent Damascene conversion, signed his country up to the Net Zero by 2050 target of COP 21 in Paris.
“The last chance saloon”: Prince Charles welcomes attendees at COP 25 in Glasgow. Image nbcnews.com
Following COP25, the Glasgow Financial Alliance for Net Zero (GFANZ) and their flagship offshoot the Net Zero Banking Alliance (NZBA) was set up by the Governor of the Bank of England, Mark Carney (more on Mark Carney later). The NZBA was a cartel of over 140 banks and financial institutions that colluded to deny funding for fossil fuel exploration, development and infrastructure, the money to be transferred instead to finance renewable energy schemes. The alliance reportedly controlled $130 trillion in assets – around one third of global GDP.
Mendicant Governments, NGOs, Institutions and all manner of Activist organisations lined up for the chance to get their fingers sticky in that honey pot.
But the NZBA cartel rapidly foundered on harsh economic realities. It was formally disbanded on October 3rd, 2025, following its abandonment by virtually all major US, European and Japanese banks (5).
With hindsight, COP25 in Glasgow now increasingly appears to have been the “last chance saloon” for the economic madness of climate alarmists.
But the annual UN boondoggles continued with ever increasing futility. The most recent COP in November 2025 (COP 31) and was held in the Amazonian town of Belem in Brazil on the 10th anniversary of the Paris Agreement. The meeting inevitably ended, as all previous ones had done, in disagreement and recrimination: much bloviating, posturing and virtue signaling, nothing of substance achieved.
It is hard to escape the fact that the Paris Agreement for Net Zero by 2050 is now a sick joke more honored in the breach than the observance by those countries foolish enough to ratify it.
Paris 2025: Nemesis
MARK CARNEY RECANTS
The wokest banker of them all. Formerly Governor of the Bank of England, the UN Special Envoy on Climate Action, instigator of the Net Zero Banking Alliance. Now Prime Minister of Canada.
Carney is now steadily walking back the draconian CO2 abatement schemes of his predecessor Justin Trudeau (see footnote 6).
Meanwhile global coal consumption and atmospheric CO2 levels reached record highs in 2025 (7).
BILL GATES RECANTS
The world’s first centi-billionaire and public philanthropist. A longtime supporter of Climate activism.
On October 2025 (just before COP 30 in Brazil), Gates issued a statement saying:
“Climate Change does not pose an existential threat to civilisation”.
Matching actions to words, Gates severely cut back the funding and activities of his climate advocacy and policy group Breakthrough Energy, stating that his money would be better spent on combating disease and poverty.
JAMES HANSEN RECANTS
Former Director of the NASA-Goddard Institute for Space Studies. Widely acknowledged as the “father” of the Catastrophic Anthropogenic Global Warming (CAGW) scare.
In 2024, James Hansen, wrote:
“Suggesting that renewables will let us phase rapidly off fossil fuels in the United States, China, India or the world as a whole is almost the equivalent of believing in the Easter Bunny or the Tooth Fairy”.
MEANWHILE, BACK IN THE WORLD OF SCIENCE
Data obtained by NASA from their MODIS platforms (low spatial, high temporal resolution, multispectral, earth observation satellites) show that from the time their global observations began in 2003, the area affected by fires has declined by 30%.
Globally, over the past 23 years, the area affected by fires has declined by over 30%. This includes cropland and savannah as well as tropical, temperate and boreal forests. The data does not provide grounds for concern.
An October 2025 paper (8) published in the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society shows that species level extinctions due to climate change ”have not significantly increased over the last approximately 200 years” thus hopefully putting an end to the absurd claim by the World Wildlife Fund (WWF) and other green groups that CAGW is causing or will cause the Sixth Mass Extinction event in the history of life on earth.
Numerous peer-reviewed papers have been published (for references see footnote 9) showing that the majority of small, populated Pacific and Indian ocean island nations have been either stable or grown in area over the past few decades despite sea level rise over that time. These include these poster children of climate catastrophists – the island nations of The Maldives, Tuvalu and Vanuatu. Despite this, the Australian Climate Change Minister Chris Bowen in October 2026 told reporters how he had stood, alone, on the foreshore of Funafuti and seen for himself the devastating effects of sea level rise on the island, thus demonstrating once again how many true believers are driven by ignorance and ideological blindness and are ignorant of, or resolutely ignore, actual scientific evidence.
Throughout the world, ticking Climate “Doomsday clock” countdowns (they come in many forms) are regularly reset or quietly abandoned to avoid them becoming an embarrassing permanent record of failed prediction.
Satellite reflectance imagery from NASA demonstrates that, since this data became available in 1980, the world has become around 20% greener (i.e.- an increase in the Leaf Area Index or LAI) largely as a result of increasing atmospheric CO2 fertilisation (10). As an additional benefit, studies of leaf stomata show that high atmospheric CO2 levels increase the drought tolerance of plants, enabling them to colonise once desert areas. Largely as a result of these factors, yields of all major global food crops have been steadily increasing since the 1960s (see 11 and, 12).
The evidence cited above shows that we are living in a golden age of agricultural abundance. Fears of widespread famine due to overpopulation – the great Malthusian scare of the 1970s and 1980s – are now a thing of the past.
The world in 2024, from reflectance satellite data. All green areas have shown an increase in plant growth over the previous 45 years, yellow, red and purple a decrease. Desert areas (white) have decreased in area over that period. Source of data: NASA
A laboratory experiment showing the effects of atmospheric CO2 concentration on the growth of Monterey pines.
According to data compiled by the International Disaster Database (CRE/EMDAT) based at the University of Louvain, Belgium, deaths from weather-related natural disasters over the 100 year period 1922-2019 (after adjusting for global population increase) have declined by over 95%.
For a more detailed breakdown of the above graph see footnote 13.
In 2025, coral cover on Australia’s Great Barrier Reef , the World’s largest coral reef and an UNESCO World Heritage Area, was at its highest level since detailed surveys began more than 40 years ago.
Graph compiled by Peter Ridd from the Australian Institute of Marine Science annual surveys of the entire 2300 km length of the reef.
A paper published in 2025 by Mark England (and 3 co-authors) in the Journal Geophysical Research Letters, showed that the extent of Arctic sea ice had been stable over the preceding 20-year period. They described their finding as “robust”, “surprising” and “not unexpected” (even although expectations are about foresight and surprises are about hindsight). They labelled this state a “pause” and, by searching through the thousands of climate model simulations in the CMIP5 and 6 archives (Coupled Model Intercomparison Project), they found that a number of them had been able to produce just such a pause. So, no worries for true believers then: just a pause, progress towards the ecological collapse of northern latitudes will resume shortly. We just don’t know when: could be next year, could take another ten. The CMIP climate simulations would be more useful and believable if researchers had been able to use them to predict the “pause” before it occurred, rather than just providing a possible explanation for it after. A theory that can explain everything predicts nothing. That, sadly, is the state of much institutional Climate Science today.
The “pause” was certainly an Inconvenient Truth for Al Gore who, in 2009, declared that all Arctic ice would be gone by 2014.
The balance of opinion in published climate science is slowly shifting. Sceptical scientists are now increasingly getting their papers published and having alarmist papers retracted, even by those former gatekeepers of CAGW orthodoxy – the editors of the leading Journals Science and Nature (see HERE).
The Museum of Once-Fashionable Science.
But most POLITICIANS, LAWYERS and MEDIA still IGNORE EVIDENCE in FAVOUR of IDEOLOGY
Two egregious examples (among the many I could quote):
(1) In 2024 and 2025, the UN Secretary General António Guterres, variously declared that it is: “Climate crunch time”, that “The oceans are boiling” and that “Planet Earth is being pushed beyond its limits”. However, Guterrez helpfully added: “There is an exit off the highway to climate hell”.
The “exit” Antonio was referring to is the 2015 Paris Agreement for Net Zero by 2050.
In a 2019 photo-op for Time Magazine, António Guterres, waded into the waters off Funafuti (the capital island of the Tuvalu Archipelago) to illustrate rising sea levels. The performative stunt proved nothing about sea levels but at least served to demonstrate that the ocean is not boiling (he looks rather cold).
(2) In July 2025, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) - sixteen unelected and unaccountable lawyers sitting in The Hague – declared a “human right” to avoiding the “indisputable, urgent and existential threat” of Climate Change. The President of the Court Yugi Iwasawa added extra hyperbole by adding that Climate Change was an “an existential problem of planetary proportions that imperils all forms of life and the very health of our planet” (source AP News, July 23, 2025).
The ICJ has (thankfully) no enforcement powers but their opinions matter. These will inevitably, as intended, encourage and enable years of future litigation and lawfare, holding up vital investment and providing good livings for legions of lawyers around the world.
Sixteen unelected lawyers sitting in The Hague. Although nominated from mostly Third World countries, their lawyerly dress, pretensions and left-wing opinions are pure European
But lawyers step outside their legal role to become political activists when they pronounce on complex and contested scientific matters in which they have no knowledge, training or credibility.
And few politicians ever see a passing bandwagon parade that they do feel the urge to join.
No doubt most of the members of these groups are sincere and well-meaning people who see themselves as noble Saviors of the Planet. But they possess neither the wit or wisdom to realise that the wheels of their bandwagon are wobbly and about to fall off, and the cheering crowds urging them on are rapidly thinning as activists move on to more fashionable causes. Where once they shouted, “Climate Action Now”, today they shout, “Free Palestine” or ”Globalise the Intifada”.
But what of the climate scientists who designed, built and still drive the Climate Change bandwagon? The majority pay service (or at least lip-service) to the climate catastrophe meme. It is worth remembering that these scientists are dependent for their funding – their very careers – on politicians. The scientists scare the public, media and Government with their doomsday models. Politicians, suitably scared, then support said scientists with oceans of money. It is a vicious, self-reinforcing ouroboros loop (14), armored against all evidence and reason (see my previous posts, The Mathew Effect and There is no Wisdom in Crowds).
As Upton Sinclair presciently pointed out in 1934:
“It difficult to get someone to understand something when his career depends upon his not understanding it”.
Fads and fashions in the wider, non-scientific community (cultural memes) are relatively ephemeral and tend to appear and disappear suddenly and mysteriously. But scientific memes (usually dignified by the name of paradigms) that have the weight and inertia of established Institutions behind them can take decades to die out as their adherents, one by one, retire or die. Science advances by questioning established paradigms, but few academic or institutional scientists are prepared to do this, preferring a comfortable life competing with each other inside the laager for government grants. ”In this closed environment dissenters soon learn that objection carries a cost their conformist colleagues never pay”.
Because they have invested so little time in acquiring them, the enthusiasms and opinions of the young can change easily (15), but for the heavily invested old, the process takes much longer. The years of hard study and training that it takes to master a field of science can impose rigidity of thought and resistance to new ideas. Ominously, to this human failing a new and additional rigidity is now being imposed on institutional science by AI Large Language Models, all of which are “trained” on orthodoxy and consensus as part of their basic architecture (16). AI is a powerful tool but is incapable of thinking outside the box unless carefully guided and prompted by a real intelligence.
THERE is HOPE BUT THERE IS ALSO A WARNING
“It is easier to fool people than to persuade them they have been fooled” Mark Twain
For sceptics, although many battles were won in 2025 and the possibility of an end to the struggle is in sight (say not the struggle naught availeth), it is too soon to celebrate. The war on the Climate Change doomsday cult is far from won. As 2025 rolls over into 2026, die-hard cultists, both institutional scientists and the useful idiots who support them, have merely retired to lick their wounds, plan new strategies and double down on their alarmist predictions. ”They do not see reality as evidence of their extremism, but as evidence that they were not extreme enough”.
So be warned. In a re-purposed garage near you, the local branch of the Climate Change doomsday cult is currently doubling down and working hard…
Swimming in an ocean of hydrocarbon products, useful idiots are working hard.
******
(Updated and reformatted March and August, 2026)
Footnotes and References
(1) The title of this post is the opening line from an 1855 poem by Arthur Hugh Clough. “Say not the struggle naught availeth, The labour and the wounds are vain: The enemy faints not nor faileth, As things have been they yet remain…. But Westward, look, the land is bright”. Winston Churchill popularised the quote in a speech to the House of Commons in the dark days of 1940.
(2) Around 2010, the Catastrophic Anthropogenic Global Warming meme was in trouble. Global average temperatures had been in slight decline for over ten years; the 2009 UN Climate Conference (COP 15 in Copenhagen) was an acknowledged failure with no agreement among its 60,000+ delegates; the Northern Hemisphere winter of 2009-10 was one of the coldest and snowiest in decades and thousands of hacked (or leaked?) emails from the Climate Research Unit at the University of East Anglia had been made public in 2009 demonstrating years of malpractice and scientific finagling by prominent CAGW researchers - a scientific scandal that became known as Climategate.
In this winter of their discontent, to meet the crisis, the promoters of the CAGW meme cynically changed its name from Global Warming to Climate Change. This not only provided an easily remembered alliterative handle for their cause but had the additional advantage of allowing them to attribute any future extreme weather event – be it heat or cold, flood or drought, calm or storm, scarcity or overabundance – to rising CO2 levels. It was a theory immune to falsification because, for every bad event that happened, they were able to argue “rising atmospheric CO2 levels caused it”. How? Because correlation means causation - Right?
But a theory that can explain everything, predicts nothing.
(3) Source: Our World in Data. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/global-energy-substitution
(4) Averages obscure individual reality. If Elon Musk walks into a bar, everyone there instantly becomes a billionaire, on average. No one experiences a global average temperature: a global average telephone number would be about as useful.
(5) Source: New York Times. https://nytimes.com/2026/01/17/climate/how-wall-street-turned-its-back-on-climate-change.html
(6) On gaining office in March 2025, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney immediately abolished the Federal Government carbon tax and the EV mandates of his predecessor Justin Trudeau. Later that year he indicated approval of the 2000km Keystone XL Pipeline, cancelled by Trudeau in 2017. The pipeline is designed to take crude oil from Alberta oil fields to refineries in the western and mid-western United Sates. He also approved construction of a new pipeline from Alberta to Canadian west coast refineries and ports. At the same time Carney encouraged increased production from the Athabascan Tar Sands of NE Alberta. In March 2026, during a State visit to Tokyo, Carney emphasised Canada’s ability and willingness to double its LNG exports.
(7) Source: International Energy Agency. https://www.iea.org/reports/coal-25/executive-summary
(8) K. E. Saban & J. J. Weins. Proceedings of the Royal Society Oct 2025. Unpacking the extinction crisis: Rates, patterns and causes of recent extinctions in plants and animals. Proceedings of Biological Science (2025)292(2057): https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2025.1717
(9) P.S. (Paul) Kench et al. (4 co-authors), 2015. Geology 43(6), pp 515-518. Coral islands defy sea-level rise over the past century: Records from a Central Pacific atoll. https://doi.org/10.1130/G36555.1
P.S. Kench et al.(2 co-authors) 2018. Nature Communications. Patterns of island change and persistence offer alternate adaptation pathways for atoll nations. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-018-02954-1
P.S.Kench et al. (11 co-authors) 2023: Nature Communications. Reef islands have continually adjusted to environmental change over the past two millennia. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-36171-2
(10) Piao et al. 2019: Characteristics, drivers and feedbacks of global greening. Nat. Rev. Earth & Envir. https://doi.org/10.1038/s43017-019-0001-x
N. Anniwaer et al (6 co-authors) 2026: Vegetation greenness in 2025. Nat. Rev. Earth & Envir. 7, 209-212. https://doi.org/10.1038/s43107-026-00776-0
(11) Sources:
Our World in Data- https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/key-crop-yields
and… Nat. Rev. Earth & Envir. 7, pp 209-212 (2026): Vegetation Greenness in 2025. https://doi.org/10.1038/s43017-026-00776-0
(12) An additional factor in the ever-increasing yields of all major food crops is the ever-increasing use of nitrate fertiliser, a product known as urea - CO(NH2)2. It is made using the Bosch-Meiser Process. The nitrogen comes from the atmosphere, abundant, ubiquitous and free. The hydrogen, carbon and energy to drive the process come from natural gas. The cost of nitrate fertiliser is thus largely the cost of natural gas.
The effect of nitrogen fertiliser on a crop of wheat. Photo source: Deli Chen, University of Melbourne
(13) Source: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/decadal-deaths-disasters-type.png
(14) Ouroboros: An ancient symbol of a snake eating its own tail. An endless loop. A vicious circle.
If you Google this word, you will be informed that it is an ancient symbol representing: ”the infinite loop of time”. Whatever that means. In my opinion: meaningless baloney. To me, the meaning is perfectly clear: evil eventually destroys itself.
(15) On ephemeral cultural memes: as a boy, I remember the schoolyard fashion for Yo-Yos (spinning tops on the end of a string). The craze came from nowhere and swept the world but lasted all of two years. Today, for the young as I write, it is six-seven. And no, I don’t know what that means either. Wikipedia doesn’t know what it means, and I think that’s rather the point. When old guys like me (and you too, dear reader, if you’re over 16) get to hear of a pop-meme, it’s almost certainly yesterday’s thing.
But fashionable Science memes last a good deal longer.
(16) Joe Nalvan Jan 5, 2026: AI Models and Their “Knowledge” of Climate Change. https://judithcurry.com






